Book reviews, new books, publishing news, book giveaways, and author interviews

Book Review: Mr Toppit by Charles Elton

mr toppit charles elton Book Review: Mr Toppit by Charles Elton


Christopher Robin Milne, embattled star of the Winnie the Pooh'books, was known to have been highly ambivalent about his life having been exploited in his fathers books. In Mr Toppit, the debut of Charles Eltonan author who has worked with the Milne estate in a literary agent capacitya similar situation is examined, but in the present context of mass media, the paparazzi, and the publics insatiable appetite for celebrity.

Luke Hayman is the nearly eponymous hero of The Hayseed Chronicles, a series of childrens books that have attained modest success for its small-time English publisher. However, upon the abrupt death of Lukes father, the author of the series, a series of odd events sees the books reach grow dramatically to what seems like quasi-Harry Potter popularity. Mr Toppit'examines the'media flurry that follows and the effect that it has on the quiet, quintessentially English Hayman family and those who have slowly insinuated themselves into the familys lives. Theres Luke, an introvert who longs to be out of the public eye; Lukes sister Rachel, who leaps on to the publicity bandwagon despite being very noticeably absent from the books themselves; Arthur Haymans widow, Martha, a vaguely crazed woman who withdraws, somewhat playfully, into eccentricity; and of course Laurie Clows, the American who by chance becomes a part of the Hayseed collective and who is largely responsible for the books becoming the bizarre juggernaut they do.

Mr Toppit'is an unsettling book, but its an unsettled one as well. The book opens with a suggestion of magic realism, perhaps, or at least of something a little dark and moody, if occasionally beset by whimsy. Perhaps this is due to the English setting of the book: the dreary, fairytale-esque vibe full of rambling buildings, people in threadbare suits and woods that threaten in the periphery with all sorts of possibilities. But when Arthurs death sees the mass media and the shadow of celebrity seep in, the tone of the book becomes something very distant from its original promises. We travel from the damp English country-side, the perfect setting for what seems almost to be an old-fashioned comedy of manners into the glare of California, and the books mood shifts quite dramatically. Gone are the awkward family silences and the pensive ponderings to be replaced by sex, drugs, rock n roll, and the incessant search for money.

Im afraid that with this shift my investment in Mr Toppit'gradually dwindled: though I appreciated Eltons examination of this strange garish world and the disconnect with it his characters felt, the mood of the book gradually falls away into something more akin to a chick lit novel than the quiet and gloomy fairytale-inspired story that seems to be promised at the books outset. However, amidst the sprawl of what does follow there is a good deal of food for thought: the effect on Rachel from her utter exclusion from the books, for one (Luke wonders just how hard it would have been to have added and Rachel into the narrative), and the burning desire of Laurie to be accepted, the impetus behind which she scarcely understand herself, but which we learn has to do with her own Mr Toppit lurking quietly in the background. And, of course, theres Luke himself, watching a bigger, better version of his life rendered in a series of books, and eventually in a film as wellthere are so many Lukes that Luke finds himself a lone voice crying that he'is the original, the Luke who has had his life and identity stolen and exploited.

There are moments of Mr Toppit'that I adored: the snippets from the books, which seem to have an eerie Oz-meets-Faust'quality, and which make one wonder why on earth an author would subject even a fictitious version of their son to such things; the desperate has-been illustrator Lila, who is determined to reclaim her foothold in the family and its subsequent successes; and the occasional moments of beauty that occur between Luke and Rachel. But unfortunately as a whole I felt that the novel lacked the cohesion I expected, perhaps in part because I felt that what I was promised at the outset didnt quite eventuate.

Still, its worth picking up for that cover alone.

Rating: star Book Review: Mr Toppit by Charles Eltonstar Book Review: Mr Toppit by Charles Eltonhalfstar Book Review: Mr Toppit by Charles Eltonblankstar Book Review: Mr Toppit by Charles Eltonblankstar Book Review: Mr Toppit by Charles Elton (not bad)

Support Read in a Single Sitting by purchasing Mr Toppit from

Amazon | Book Depository UK | Book Depository USA | Booktopia

This book appears on our list of books about books


  1. I enjoyed reading your review, although I liked the book itself more than you did. I thought the book was marketed in a misleading way, so it wasnt what readers were expecting when they picked it up.
    My thoughts:

  2. Stephanie /

    Thanks for visiting, Laurie. I completely agree with you that this one was marketed oddlyI was certainly expecting some sort of magic realism approach, or even a horror or fantasy novel, and I wonder how much that affected my eventual enjoyment of the book. Heading over to check out your review now. :)